AI models like those powering MyEssayFeedback.ai and ChatGPT can generate useful feedback on student writing, but interpreting that feedback effectively requires guidance — especially for instructors and students new to AI-assisted writing.
1. Understand the context: Feedback is shaped by the prompt given to the AI and the type of feedback selected by your instructor. A prompt focused on thesis development produces different feedback than one focused on grammar. Knowing what the AI was asked to evaluate helps you interpret its suggestions accurately.
2. Don't take it as absolute truth: AI models are powerful but not perfect. They can miss nuance, misread your intent, or suggest changes that don't fit your purpose. Treat AI feedback as one informed perspective, not a definitive judgment.
3. Look for patterns: If you submit multiple drafts or receive feedback on several essays, look for recurring themes. Consistent notes about weak transitions or unsupported claims likely point to real areas for growth.
4. Use it as a starting point: AI feedback works best as a launching pad for deeper thinking. Use it to spark conversations with your instructor, writing tutor, or peers.
5. Incorporate human feedback: AI cannot replace the insight of a human reader who understands your assignment, your voice, and your growth as a writer. Use AI feedback alongside instructor comments, peer review, and structured reflection.
6. Don't rely on it too heavily: The most important skills — developing your argument, finding your voice, thinking critically — come from practice, not from following AI suggestions uncritically.
For more on how to think critically about AI suggestions, see our template phrases for reflecting on AI feedback by Anna Mills, or explore our Critical AI Literacy guide.